'I've looked': Gary Lineker and Alan Shearer share their verdict on late penalty for West Ham vs Man United

https://cdn1.tbrfootball.com/uploads/27/2024/10/GettyImages-2181362766-1024x683.jpg

Manchester United's trip down to east London to face West Ham United certainly wasn't short of action.

First of all, Erik ten Hag's Man United side should have probably secured the three points by half time – West Ham were being carved apart in the first half.

However, a remarkable Diogo Dalot miss among others kept West Ham in the game, who were eventually able to score two goals to win the game.

Julen Lopetegui promised Crysencio Summerville game time when he signed him in the summer, and although he didn't start the match, he was still on hand to tuck home his big chance.

Of course, it was another sub, Danny Ings, who was involved in an extremely controversial VAR call which ultimately saw Man United lose the game late on.

VAR were wrong to award West Ham a penalty for Matthijs de Ligt ‘foul’

Matthijs de Ligt was punished for a 'foul' on Ings in the box, one that the referee, David Coote, didn't originally award but then changed his mind once VAR intervened.

Speaking on 'The Rest is Football' podcast, both Gary Lineker and Alan Shearer shared their honest thoughts on the incident, one they thought was 'baffling'.

Photo by James Gill – Danehouse/Getty Images

READ MORE: Pundit says Manchester United man was 'leading by example' despite losing to West Ham

Neither pundit thought a penalty should have been awarded, a 'terrible' intervention by VAR.

Lineker said: "The penalty decision that won it for West Ham, well, I mean, I've looked at it about eight times and I can't see anything close to resembling a foul, let alone the fact that the referee didn't give it and then VAR turned it over.

"It looks like a mistake from me."

Shearer added: "Well you look at it another 80 times and you're still not going to find anything because the referee didn't give the penalty.

"Then he's been told by VAR to go and have a look at the screen, which, okay, but it's baffling that two really experienced referees can look at that and both of them them think, particularly David Coote, the referee thinks, I've made an absolute howler here and I'm going to go with what the VAR is telling me.

"It was a terrible decision, it really was. I mean, Man United would look to that and blame that, but they've only got themselves to blame for the chances they missed in the first half."

PGMOL failing to find consistency across the Premier League

Although West Ham were the beneficiaries of a poor decision on this occasion, it's easily one that could go against them in future.

The PGMOL stated that there would be a higher threshold before VAR got involved and overturned referee decisions this season.


And in the eyes of many, there's not even a foul let alone a clear and obvious mistake by Cooke, who got it right on his first interpretation.

Erik ten Hag is right to feel aggrieved, a manager who is under so much pressure right now.

And even if United missed several gilt-edged chances, it still feels unjust that they lost the game in the manner in which they did.

img

Top 5 Football

×